Lessons from Fukushima: The Nuclear Industry's Key Challenges in the Aftermath of Japan's Disaster
(MENAFN Press) Japan is still reeling from theearthquakeand tsunami that struck its north-east coast in March 2011.
The disasterseverely disabled the multi-unit Fukushima Daiichi nuclear facilitylocated on the Pacific coast of kuma, causing an unpredictable crisis situation and seriousconcerns over the safety of the nuclear power industry.
Management consulting firmBooz & Companyhas established that, to secure a future for nuclear power, the industry mustincorporate the lessons of Fukushima into its operational planning, and develop improved risk analysis and project management capabilities.
IMMEDIATE RESPONSE POST-FUKUSHIMA
The most immediate response to the events at Fukushima Daiichi came from politicians.
Political leaders in Japan are still in a debate about whether to keep the country's other reactors offline, given their similarities with the Fukushima design as well as questions about local siting conditions.
Within two months, all of Japan's plants were shut down and it was more than a year before the first one reopened in June 2012.
Manyother nations quickly followed suit: Germany planned to phase out itsnuclear plants by 2022 and even in France, then-opposition leader and now president Franois Hollande called for shutting down 28 of its 58 reactors by 2025.
Reactions also affected some of the proposals for nuclear energy expansion that had gathered momentum in the previous years.
Several countriesdecided to cancel all new constructions;the net effect of the shutdowns was significant as approximately 15 percent of current capacity was taken offline “ at least temporarily “ by the end of 2011.
In the Middle East in particular, reactions differed per nation: while some delayed or shelved their announced nuclear energy programs, others were less prone to do so.
In the UAE, TheEmirates Nuclear Energy Corporation's plans to build four reactors over the next decade or so “ for a total capacity of 5.6 GW “went ahead as intended and even crossed two major milestones earlier this year.
The company received regulatory approval and awarded procurement contracts to various international firms for the supply of nuclear fuel to cover 15 years of operations and has integrated the lessons learnt from Fukushima.
In truth, much of this progress is due to the UAE's strong adoption of the highest standards of security, transparency and non-proliferation. Because of this careful, safety-driven approach, the country is considered a true role model by international organizations as well as other regional states.
"Despite the UAEbeing rich in oil andgas, nuclear energy is still seen as a safe and cost-effective source of powerneeded to produce water," said George Sarraf, Partner with Booz & Company.
"Itprovides an opportunity to free up oil and gas resources for export or other value-add uses, create domestic growth and diversify the energy mix by embracing new sustainable and clean sources of energy."
At A Crossroads
In the aftermath of the incident, public and political responses were also mixed; while some believed that the role of nuclear technology as a viable source of power was diminished, others viewed the catastrophe as a localized highly improbable phenomenon with few long-term implications.
Despite the setbacks, the nuclear industry's longstanding history is still recognized as exemplary on a global scale. Currently, nuclear power accounts for about 368 gigawatts (GW) of installed capacity.
"Given this hefty contribution, energy decision makers “ including government leaders, regulators, and executives in the nuclear industry “ must approach both the short- and long-term response to Fukushima pragmatically," said Tom Flaherty, a Senior Partner with Booz & Company.
"They need to contemplatehow to build in better preventive measures and responses in the future."
CHARTING A NEW COURSE
As result of the crisis, significant emphasis was placed on reforming thenuclear regulatory process.Several nations initiated safety reviews and the United States' Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) “considered a world leader in nuclear power oversight “formed its Fukushima Daiichi Near-Term Task Force and completed itsevaluation in July 2011.
An Adequate Regulatory Framework
"The resulting NRC recommendations are built on the "design basis" principle, which has long been the foundation for nuclear power reactor regulations," explainedChristopher Dann, a Partner with Booz & Company.
"They include more stringent requirements for the design and construction of nuclear plants, intended to ensure that these can withstand a more extreme accident than Fukushima without loss to the systems, structures, and components necessary to ensure public health and safety."
The NRC's first orders include:
1.Establishing a logical, systematic, and coherent regulatory framework.
2.Requiring licensees to reevaluate and upgrade their design-basis seismic and flooding protection.
3.Evaluating longer-term potential enhancements to the ability to prevent or mitigate seismically induced fires and floods.
While the nuclear industry supports these three orders, it is less clear what will be the ultimate price tag of implementing the full equipment, instrumentation, and software fixes related to the current orders, and just how manageable or costly any forthcoming requirements will be.
The real challenge to the economics of nuclear power lies in the current low natural gas price environment, not the new safety requirements.
If other countries implement similar regulatory regimes, planning for nuclear power's future will entail design modifications and enhanced administrative actions.
"The nuclear industry shouldbroaden its understanding of operating risk and its implications at both the plant and enterprise levels, with an eye towards prevention as well as improved response," added Dann.
"It should also enhance its project management capabilities to successfully deliver the next generation of new nuclear units.
Both of these capabilities require an increased level of transparency into the industry's decision-making processes.
While this will be a challenge, it also offers an opportunity for the industry to demonstrate its commitment to superior risk management, design, planning, and execution."
Lessons in Risk Management
After Fukushima, the way in which the industry evaluates risk must change, and owner resiliency and responsiveness willneed to increase.
Operators also have to develop enhanced risk analysis methodologies.
The industry must strengthen its current methodologies and improve existing processes and tools “ tohelp identify potential risks.
Traditional thinking about 'known unknowns' must be expanded to include 'unknown unknowns', as such scenario planning can be a useful tool in expanding leaders' range of thinking when assessing risks and vulnerabilities.
The end goal is to develop an industry-wide approach to defining and quantifying Fukushima-level improbable events, which will both satisfy regulatory safety requirements and assuage public concerns, while being implementable and cost-effective.
A further imperative involves building the plant, enterprise, and industry resilience needed to withstand these unpredictable events.
THE FUTURE OF NUCLEAR POWER
To retain its long-term credibility, the nuclear industry must diverge as little as possible from its planned investment levels and schedule.
If projects currently on the drawing board fail to deliver on expectations for cost and schedule performance, the ability to build the next-generation nuclear fleet will be impaired.
It is actually fortunate that the nuclear renaissance “ the economic revitalization of the nuclear power industry “ has begun slowly as it providesowners, original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) and engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) groups withadditional time to improve procedures.
"Successful construction of a nuclear plant hinges on the ability of its owners to deploy effective project management capabilities, including project planning, progress measurement, and direct oversight, as well as the detailed performance metrics and insightful reporting processes necessary to achieve a successful project outcome," said Flaherty.
"A robust project capabilities framework that addresses all the activities required to complete construction can provide owners with a model for project management success."
A well-designed project management framework alone will not ensure success; owners must also overcome constraints in resources, limits to process rigor and controls, and infrastructure inadequacy.
The nuclear industry must reassure both regulators and the public that the current nuclear operating fleet is safe, and this can only be achieved if it is willing to submit to an increasingly rigorous regulatory regime.
Leaders within this sector should also remind themselves and others of its track record as a decades-long model for safe and reliable operations,as this will provide the political capital needed to guarantee the future roleof nuclear power.
Owners and operators will need capabilities of intelligent risk management and high-touch project execution to build the next cycle of nuclear plants within established cost and schedule frameworks “ as well as achieve high levels of quality in construction and operations.
Building these capabilities is a critical step in establishing a 'right to play' in energy generation and enabling the industry's future.
About Booz & Company
Booz & Company is a leading global management consulting firm focused on serving and shaping the senior agenda of the world's leading institutions. Our founder, Edwin Booz, launched the profession when he established the first management consulting firm in Chicago in 1914. Today, we operate globally with more than 3,000 people in 60 offices around the world.We believe passionately that essential advantage lies within and that a few differentiating capabilities drive any organization's identity and success. We work with our clients to discover and build those strengths and capture the market opportunities where they can earn the right to win.We are a firm of practical strategists known for our functional expertise, industry foresight, and "sleeves rolled up" approach to working with our clients. To learn more about Booz & Company or to access its thought leadership, visit booz.com. Our award-winning management magazine, strategybusiness, is available at strategy-business.com.
MENA News Headlines
|Mar 9 2014||Libya separatists load NKorea oil ship and ignore warning ,AFP|
(MENAFN - AFP) Libyan separatists loaded oil onto a North Korean tanker for a second consecutive day on Sunday, ignoring the central government's threats of military action, an industry official ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Al Hamra launches USD272 m project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE's Al Hamra Real Estate Development has announced the opening of the USD 272 million Falcon Island project in Ras Al Khaimah, according to Khaleej Times.
The new project aims to ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman aims to increase non-oil exports by 15 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman is aiming to increase the value of its non-oil exports by 15 percent this year, Times of Oman reported.
The Director of Export Development at Ithraa said that Oman's exports of ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman's government revenue drops 7.9 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman's National Centre for Statistics and Information (NCSI) said that the country's government revenues dropped 7.9 percent in January, Times of Oman reported.
The NCSI said that ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman's foreign trade up 9.1 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Statistics released by the Omani National Centre for Statistics and Information (NCSI) show an increase in the Sultanate's foreign trade, Times of Oman reported.
The data show that the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Dubai-based Deyaar plans USD245m residential, hotel project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based Deyaar Development announced its plan to build a residential and hotel project in Dubai, Arabian Business reported.
The project, at a total cost of USD245 million, will consist ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Jumbo plans expansion ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based retail electronics giant Jumbo Group announced that it plans to expand its engineering and B2B businesses as well as its retail footprint in the GCC, India and Iran, Arabian ...|
|Mar 9 2014||New fashion company plans IPO in Dubai ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) A retailing company still being formed is planning for its first initial public offering (IPO) on Dubai's main stock market in five years, Arabian Business reported.
The company will ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's du signs agreement with international telecom companies ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) du, the Middle East"s fastest growing telecom service provider, has joined an international consortium that includes several telecom companies to build South East Asia - Middle East -Western ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's RTA wins USD27 m contract ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE's Board of Directors of the Roads & Transport Authority (RTA) has won a contract to construct and collector internal roads at Al Barsha South 1 and Al Barsha South 2, according to the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Dubai's Emirates to sign off USD76 b deal with Boeing ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Dubai"s Emirates said it will cancel its USD76 billion purchase of Boeing 777X wide-body planes for reasons, such as performance guarantees, according to Arabian Business.
The order ...|
|Mar 9 2014||La Liga Preview: Real Madrid v Levante ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Carlo Ancelotti's side rescued a 3-2 win at Estadi Ciutat de Valencia in October with stoppage-time goals from Alvaro Morata and Cristiano Ronaldo.
They will enter this weekend's ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Steyn, Johnson absent for T20 series ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Mitchell Johnson has been rested for the three-match series, returning to Australia ahead of the World Twenty20 in Bangladesh.
Dale Steyn battled through South Africa's third Test ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Lee, Son progress to Birmingham last four ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Malaysia's Lee thrashed Japan's Kento Momota 21-14 21-18 in their quarter-finals at the National Indoor Arena in Birmingham.
He will face Son Wan Ho in the last four after the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Copa Libertadores Preview: Atletico Mineiro, Velez Sarsfield near progression ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Both teams have claimed two wins from as many games in their groups and a third € halfway through the stage € would set them up nicely.
Mineiro have edged their way to the top of ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Davids: Del Piero should delay coaching plans ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora)
The Sydney FC star, 39, is nearing the end of his career and is yet to re-sign with the A-League club, having been linked with another move to Asia.
Davids, who played alongside ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Blanc confirms Cavani will miss Bastia trip ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora)Cavani returned to Uruguay earlier in the week for personal reasons and will not be back in time for Saturday's match.
The 27-year-old has scored 14 goals in 22 league appearances ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Barca are not in decline, Xavi insists ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Barca secured three La Liga titles, two Copa del Rey medals and twice won the UEFA Champions League under the stewardship of former coach Pep Guardiola,
Tito Vilanova carried on ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Majid Al Futtaim sign agreement with HCT ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based retail giant Majid Al Futtaim and Higher Colleges of Technology (HCT) have signed an agreement to launch a retail academy and industry consortium, according to Arabian ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Northampton book Anglo-Welsh Cup final spot ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) George Pisi was the star of the show for the 2010 winners at Franklin's Gardens as he completed a hat-trick in the second half to complete a comfortable victory.
Saracens struggled ...|