MENAFN - Youm7
(MENAFN - Youm7) The Turkish democratic experience cannot be copied or imitated by Egypt, according to Mustafa el-Fiqi, a professor of political science at Cairo University. El-Fiqi said despite the similarities, there are many differences between Egypt and Turkey.
El-Fiqi's comments came during a conference hosted by Youm7 Center for Political Studies in cooperation with the Strategic Thinking Institute of Ankara, titled 'Democratization and Legal Constitutional Changes in Egypt and Turkey.'
El-Fiqi said there are too many differences between Egpt and Turkey to apply the came constitutional model, as secularism must be applied in Egypt because Egypt has no Atatrk, considered the father of modern Turkey.
El-Fiqi did, however, welcome mutual cooperation between both countries. He referred to Turkish Prime Minister Reccep Tayyeb Erdogan's visit to Cairo after the January 25 Revolution, which was warmly welcomed by Egyptian Islamists.
He added that secularism is not so easily applied in Egypt.
He warned of talking about democratization in Egypt, adding that Egypt's economic and political situations should be taken into consideration.
Copying and imitating the Turkish experience would be very difficult for Egypt now, but might be possible after 15 years, el-Fiqi added.
"In Egypt, we suffer from the Pharaohs. Every ruler in the presidency catches all eyes and we see another pharaoh. If the parliamentary regime achieved after years, it would be able to destroy this [cycle,]" said el-Fiqi.
The conference was opened with a speech by Youm7 Chairman Walid Mustafa, who said, " The positive impacts of the Turkish experience became clear as fruitful economic and political success appeared. Turkish political leadership has won the admiration of fair Arab nations and the world nations for this achievement."
" When the uprisings of the Arab Spring began, we noticed Turkey emerging as an effective regional power amidst the turmoil. Turkey reacted differently toward each revolution: it was indecisive regarding the Tunisian revolution, but its reaction toward Egypt was powerful and clear. Turkey looked for a diplomatic solution toward the situation in Bahrain, and was conservative regarding Libya. Turkey also tried to seek a different approach in Syria until announcing support for Syrian revolutionaries," Dr. Mustafa continued.
He said Egypt's revolution became an inspiring model for all nations of the world. "Egypt ousted the thrones of injustice, oppression, and tyranny," he said. "Egypt's youth, men, and women are seeking values, principles and ethics through a civilian government, which will move Egypt toward the horizon of advanced and civilized nations."
He added that Youm7's goal in holding the conference was to act as a bridge to reach its readers without pre-political, religious, or sectarian ideologies.
Commenting on Dr. Walid's speech on Turkey's stance towards the Arab Spring revolutions, Seluk University professor Yasin Aktay said Turkey supported the revolutions in Egypt and Tunisia, but in Libya the situation was different as the people were divided.
Aktay said Turkey tried to reconcile between the disputing parties. He quoted the Quranic verse, " If two groups of believers fight with each other, you shall reconcile them. If one group aggresses against the other, you shall fight the aggressing group until they submit to God's command. Once they submit, you shall reconcile the two groups equitably. You shall maintain justice; God loves those who are just."
Aktay also tackled the issue of democracy in Turkey and its historical changes, which began at the end of the 19th century. In the beginning, Turkey was a one-party system. After World War II, Turkish democracy transformed to a multi-party system.
However, he said Turkey does not have complete democracy, as the constitution is passed by the army. Aktay said the army takes measures against any trend who tries to come to power. Furthermore, he said political parties' activities are limited.
He added that the Turkish people are now starting to call for change and for a constitution to represent all branches of Turkish society.
Ahmet Uysal, a Middle Eastern Studies professor at Eskisehir Osmangazi University, said Turkey cares about the Arab nations, especially Egypt. He said there is an analogy in democratization between both countries, as Turkey took democracy from the army and Egypt's army is watching the democratization.
Turkish Ambassador to Cairo Al-Hussein Avni Botsali said there is cooperation between Egypt and Turkey but thtat Turkey cannot say what to or not to do, as this is an Egyptian affair.
Ginab Shaqmaq, professor at Eskisehir Osmangazi, said in his speech that the constitution is the identity of the country and signifies a contract between the people and the government. He added that the Turkish constitution adopts certain things from European constitutions.
Regarding external and internal factors that affect democratization in Egypt, Bakinam Sharqawi, a political science professor at Cairo University and the British University in Egypt, said Egypt will not be subjected to foreign intervention anymore, especially from the U.S. administration. As for applying the EU constitution in Arab countries, she said this is important because there are differences between Arab and Western countries. Moreover, she said, there are disputes among Arab and Western states regarding building democracy.
Sharqawi said focusing on the external affairs and neglecting internal affairs triggered Egypt's January 25 Revolution. She refereed to ousted president Hosni Mubarak's son, Gamal, who did not care about the people.
Zainab Dagi, a professor at Istanbul Technical University and ex-member of the Turkish Justice and Development Party, gave a speech about the future of democracy. When she was a member of the committee to Gaza after the Israeli attack on the Freedom Flotilla, she passed through Egypt. She said she asked Egyptian parliamentarians why Muslim Brotherhood members were not in the parliament, a d they told her that there is a fear of the Islamists on Egypt's Christian minority.
Daji said she admires the Egyptian and Arab uprisings that inspired the world. She gave the example that one of the Occupy Wall Street protesters in the United States said, "We started this movement because the Egyptians became a model for us."
She said this statement shows the power of Egypt.
MENA News Headlines
|Dec 12 2013||Exxon offers gasoil contract from Saudi Arabia ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Exxon Mobil Corp. made an offer for gasoil cargoes through a rare term tender from its joint-venture refinery in Saudi Arabia, Arab News reported.
Exxon Mobil offered up to 6 million ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Construction projects worth USD159b in KSA ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) The construction sector in Saudi Arabia is a key component of the country's economy development as projects worth a total of USD159 billion are underway or in the planning, Arab News ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Poland eyes investments from Qatar ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Qatar and Poland looked at opportunities to sustain cooperation in and improve trade ties between the two, The Peninsula reported.
Polish President met officials from Qatar Chamber and ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Qatar becomes pioneer in helium exports ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Qatar has become the the world"s largest helium exporter as with the inauguration of the Helium 2 plant, The Peninsula reported.
The plant incorporates the largest refining facility and ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Etihad to decide on Alitalia investment soon ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Abu Dhabi-based Etihad Airways is looking at the data room of Alitalia and is expected to decide on whether to invest in the Italian carrier by the end of the year, Arabian Business ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Habtoor Leighton to build USD395m residential towers ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Habtoor Leighton Group announced that it had won a contract with the Al Habtoor Group worth USD395 million for a residential towers project, Arabian Business reported.
Al Habtoor ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Emaar signs first deal for Expo 2020 project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Emaar Properties signed a memorandum of understanding with Dubai World Central for an urban centre and golf destination at the home of the Expo 2020 site, Arabian Business reported.
|Dec 12 2013||Dubai Economy Advances in 2013 ,Qatar News Agency|
|(MENAFN - Qatar News Agency) The year of 2013 will be remembered as a breakthrough year for Dubai as the emirate won the bid to host World Expo 2020, while witnessing strong backwinds in the field of ...|
|Dec 12 2013||UAE - Man shoots his wife over family dispute in Ras Al Khaimah ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) The 55-year-old man opened fire after a heated argument with his wife at their house at about 10.30pm.
An Emirati man shot and wounded his 47-year-old wife following a ...|
|Dec 12 2013||UAE - Cruise control fails at 140kmph, woman driver rescued ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) She was unable to bring the vehicle to a stop and called the Fujairah Police Operations Room for help.
An Emirati woman was rescued by Fujairah cops after the car's ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Police deny report of assault at Dubai airport ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) The Dubai Police have denied the news in some sections of the media regarding an alleged assault of a Saudi national at the Dubai International Airport.
A top police ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Ozonegroup plans to open office in Dubai ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) The increasing demand from the UAE and Gulf-based NRIs for the Ozone brand projects in India will be catered through the presence of Ozonegroup's local office.
|Dec 12 2013||UAE - Etisalat launches new mobile packages for high data users ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Users with either voice Data only SIMs can now take advantage of a completely unlimited mobile data package for Dh999, which is not capped at a maximum usage amount. Postpaid ...|
|Dec 12 2013||New season to bring 75 cruise ships to Abu Dhabi ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) The Abu Dhabi Tourism and Culture Authority (ADTCA) sees these passengers as future tourists for the emirate. Mohammed Al Dhaheri, strategy and policy director at ADTCA, ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Islamic finance to drive next phase of growth in Mena region ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Rapidly-growing Islamic-based finance will drive the next phase of economic growth across the Middle East and North Africa (Mena), financial leaders have said at the ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Dubai to hostâ€¨ 11 international congresses ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Dubai World Trade Centre, or DWTC, is set to welcome 11 international congresses in 2014, spanning a number of strategic industry sectors, which is expected to deliver an ...|
|Dec 12 2013||UAE and India bilateral relations contribute to stability ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Held at the Dubai World Trade Centre in collaboration with the Indian Business and Professional Council (IBPC), the roundtable formed part of a series of roundtable events in ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Dubai boostsâ€¨cooperation with UN on sustainable development ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Saeed Mohammed Al Tayer, vice-chairman of the Dubai Supreme Council of Energy, has presented the 'State of the Energy Report: Dubai 2014' to the diplomatic missions of the ...|
|Dec 12 2013||UAE - Emaar, DWC ink mega joint venture ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Emaar Properties and Dubai World Central, or DWC, announced on Wednesday a joint venture to develop an integrated urban centre and golf destination at a prime location at the ...|
|Dec 12 2013||UAE - KEF, Elematic in precast technology tie-up ,Khaleej Times|
|(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) KEF Holdings Chairman Faizal Kottikollon and Elematic CEO, Mats Jungar signed the agreement that would see the partnership being rolled out in a phased manner, first in India ...|