MENAFN - Arab News
Petroleum innovation at risk
(MENAFN - Arab News) The arrival of a swarm of activist hedge funds and investors in the oil and gas sector may be good news for corporate governance, and possibly for shareholders.
But it risks killing off the innovation and risk-taking which has revolutionized US petroleum production over the last decade and transformed the global energy outlook.
Activist Carl Icahn has finally pushed Chief Executive Aubrey McClendon out from the Chesapeake, the firm he founded in 1989, and grew into the country's second-largest producer inside two decades.
Hedge funds TPG-Axon and Mount Kellett Capital are hoping to emulate that success by ousting McClendon's disciple, Tom Ward, from the top position at SandRidge.
Now Elliott Management is targeting the venerable John Hess, son of founder Leon Hess, at the eponymous corporation by trying to stack the board with its own handpicked nominees.
Elliott is best known for stalking the Republic of Argentina through the US court system over its defaulted debts, and arresting a sail-training ship owned by the Argentine navy in Ghana before an international tribunal ordered it to be released.
The activist hedge fund has promised to boost shareholder value at Hess by installing a more independent and experienced board, refocus Hess's portfolio by spinning off its Bakken acreage and overseas assets, improve cost control and instil greater capital discipline.
The question is whether the arrival of activists with their emphasis on capital discipline, and the removal of the buccaneering entrepreneurs, will reduce the rate of innovation and harm the long-term outlook for US oil and gas production.
The positive perspective is that the leadership changes mark the maturing of the shale industry from its early pioneering, Wild West phase into a steadier and more stable state. The contrast is between the pioneering Henry Ford in the early 20th century and legendary manager Alfred Sloan at General Motors from the 1930s to 1950s.
The less positive perspective is that the activists will bring a short-term boost to shareholder value but at the cost of long-term stagnation and decline.
It was inevitable the US oil and gas sector would eventually draw the unwelcome attentions of activist funds trying to pick off the weaker members of the herd.
Oil and gas is the fastest growing industry in the US. No industry has seen a bigger transformation over the last decade. But the general upswing helped conceal very variable management performance. Now the industry has become the victim of its own success. As gas and oil output has soared and prices have fallen, the focus has shifted to cost control and execution.
Hess has not helped its own case. The company cannot decide whether it wants to be a major international oil and gas company, or a mid-sized independent oil and gas prospector in the United States.
The company's proxy statement lists a bizarre mix of companies in its self-selected comparator group: Anadarko, Apache, Devon and EOG, but also BP, Chevron, Shell, Total and Statoil, with Conoco, Marathon, Murphy, Occidental and Talisman thrown in for good measure.
With great respect to Hess, it is not Shell, Exxon or Statoil.
The one company it is not compared to is Continental Resources, which it most resembles with its Bakken position, according to Elliott Management's pitch-book, which has been filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission as part of its bid to install five new independent directors.
Investment analysts are unsure whether to classify Hess as a large-cap international oil company or a small US focused independent. Only two of the sell-side analysts covering international oil companies including Hess also cover independent US companies operating in the Bakken, according to Elliott. Hess is a composite which does not score well in any valuation category.
Elliott has criticized what it sees as the overly cosy relationship between the chief executive and the rest of the board of directors, and the resulting lack of accountability for poor performance.
In the case of Chesapeake and SandRidge, activists have gone much further, and complained about the propriety of complicated financial dealings between the companies and their chief executives, including special compensation programs that allowed the chief executive to invest alongside the company in new wells.
Lawyers will spend many happy hours arguing whether these complaints have any legal merit. But shareholders have no moral or practical reason to complain. The risks of buying into a family-owned firm, or a company with a founding or otherwise dominant chief executive, are well known.
In the case of McClendon, the chief executive can claim to be an entrepreneur as well as a manager, who created enormous amounts of value for shareholders initially.
Unlike the bland bureaucrats and accountants who run many large corporations, McClendon and Ward see themselves, with some justification, as risk-takers and value creators who built successful businesses. They are co-owners as well as managers, a status which has been recognized by the boards of their companies in their unusual compensation programs.
Compensation programs for all chief executives are always a little unusual - quis custodet ipsos custodies? The special programs created to reward McClendon and Ward are more unusual than most, but did at least align the incentives of the chief executive with those of stockholders in the exploration program.
McClendon and Ward have been felled by the declining price of gas, condensates and more recently oil, rather than governance failures. If the price of gas was still 6 or 8 per million British thermal units, no one would worry about the special compensation programs at Chesapeake and SandRidge or underperformance at Hess.
In that sense, the fracking revolution has started to devour its own children. By transforming not only the technology but the cost structure of the industry, the fracking initially created fabulous profits which then evaporated as competition intensified and output surged.
From an industry perspective, the most worrying thing about the arrival of the hedge fund activists is whether they will kill off innovation.
Activists preach shareholder value, cost control and capital discipline. Elliott quotes approvingly from a July 2012 Citigroup research report that calls for Hess to cut exploration spending 50 percent. "The company should return more cash back to shareholders instead of attempting to grow at all," Citigroup wrote.
However, small and midsized exploration and production companies like Chesapeake, Continental and Mitchell/Devon Energy, all with larger than life leaders, a willingness to innovate and take risks, have been entirely responsible for the surge in US oil and gas output. Majors like Exxon, BP and Shell played no part in the shale revolution. They were too busy focusing on capital discipline and shareholder value.
McClendon has been pilloried for his role at Chesapeake. But to shift the focus for a moment, did Apple Computer have a corporate governance problem when Steve Jobs was in charge? Transformational change is often associated with individuals with outsized personalities and an unconventional approach to management. Henry Ford is another example.
Some innovations generate huge payoffs; most fail. No rational capital-disciplined investor would have pursued the unproven and highly risky approach to horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing under the city of Forth Worth in Texas. That is why it fell to George Mitchell at Mitchell Energy and Development.
Like the railway barons of the nineteenth century, the oil and gas prospectors have over-expanded their industry based on faulty projections and a failure to understand the collective action problem (rapid growth is rational for one firm but not for the entire industry). Now they are paying the price.
MENA News Headlines
|Mar 9 2014||Libya separatists load NKorea oil ship and ignore warning ,AFP|
(MENAFN - AFP) Libyan separatists loaded oil onto a North Korean tanker for a second consecutive day on Sunday, ignoring the central government's threats of military action, an industry official ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Al Hamra launches USD272 m project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE's Al Hamra Real Estate Development has announced the opening of the USD 272 million Falcon Island project in Ras Al Khaimah, according to Khaleej Times.
The new project aims to ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman aims to increase non-oil exports by 15 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman is aiming to increase the value of its non-oil exports by 15 percent this year, Times of Oman reported.
The Director of Export Development at Ithraa said that Oman's exports of ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman's government revenue drops 7.9 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman's National Centre for Statistics and Information (NCSI) said that the country's government revenues dropped 7.9 percent in January, Times of Oman reported.
The NCSI said that ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman's foreign trade up 9.1 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Statistics released by the Omani National Centre for Statistics and Information (NCSI) show an increase in the Sultanate's foreign trade, Times of Oman reported.
The data show that the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Dubai-based Deyaar plans USD245m residential, hotel project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based Deyaar Development announced its plan to build a residential and hotel project in Dubai, Arabian Business reported.
The project, at a total cost of USD245 million, will consist ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Jumbo plans expansion ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based retail electronics giant Jumbo Group announced that it plans to expand its engineering and B2B businesses as well as its retail footprint in the GCC, India and Iran, Arabian ...|
|Mar 9 2014||New fashion company plans IPO in Dubai ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) A retailing company still being formed is planning for its first initial public offering (IPO) on Dubai's main stock market in five years, Arabian Business reported.
The company will ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's du signs agreement with international telecom companies ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) du, the Middle East"s fastest growing telecom service provider, has joined an international consortium that includes several telecom companies to build South East Asia - Middle East -Western ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's RTA wins USD27 m contract ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE's Board of Directors of the Roads & Transport Authority (RTA) has won a contract to construct and collector internal roads at Al Barsha South 1 and Al Barsha South 2, according to the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Dubai's Emirates to sign off USD76 b deal with Boeing ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Dubai"s Emirates said it will cancel its USD76 billion purchase of Boeing 777X wide-body planes for reasons, such as performance guarantees, according to Arabian Business.
The order ...|
|Mar 9 2014||La Liga Preview: Real Madrid v Levante ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Carlo Ancelotti's side rescued a 3-2 win at Estadi Ciutat de Valencia in October with stoppage-time goals from Alvaro Morata and Cristiano Ronaldo.
They will enter this weekend's ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Steyn, Johnson absent for T20 series ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Mitchell Johnson has been rested for the three-match series, returning to Australia ahead of the World Twenty20 in Bangladesh.
Dale Steyn battled through South Africa's third Test ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Lee, Son progress to Birmingham last four ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Malaysia's Lee thrashed Japan's Kento Momota 21-14 21-18 in their quarter-finals at the National Indoor Arena in Birmingham.
He will face Son Wan Ho in the last four after the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Copa Libertadores Preview: Atletico Mineiro, Velez Sarsfield near progression ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Both teams have claimed two wins from as many games in their groups and a third € halfway through the stage € would set them up nicely.
Mineiro have edged their way to the top of ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Davids: Del Piero should delay coaching plans ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora)
The Sydney FC star, 39, is nearing the end of his career and is yet to re-sign with the A-League club, having been linked with another move to Asia.
Davids, who played alongside ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Blanc confirms Cavani will miss Bastia trip ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora)Cavani returned to Uruguay earlier in the week for personal reasons and will not be back in time for Saturday's match.
The 27-year-old has scored 14 goals in 22 league appearances ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Barca are not in decline, Xavi insists ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Barca secured three La Liga titles, two Copa del Rey medals and twice won the UEFA Champions League under the stewardship of former coach Pep Guardiola,
Tito Vilanova carried on ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Majid Al Futtaim sign agreement with HCT ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based retail giant Majid Al Futtaim and Higher Colleges of Technology (HCT) have signed an agreement to launch a retail academy and industry consortium, according to Arabian ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Northampton book Anglo-Welsh Cup final spot ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) George Pisi was the star of the show for the 2010 winners at Franklin's Gardens as he completed a hat-trick in the second half to complete a comfortable victory.
Saracens struggled ...|