MENAFN - Arab News
Extreme project risk still holds back GTL
(MENAFN - Arab News) Plentiful and cheap supplies of natural gas, coupled with near-record prices for diesel and gasoline, provide a seemingly ideal environment for projects that convert natural gas into liquid transportation fuels. Yet most gas producers have hesitated to commit to new projects.
Gas-to-liquids (GTL) beats other options like pipelines, liquefied natural gas (LNG) and compressed natural gas (CNG) for smaller gas deposits stranded thousands of kilometers from consuming markets.
GTL plants are the most attractive way to realize the value in natural gas when oil prices are above 60 per barrel and gas prices are below 8 per million British thermal units, according to the 2012 "Global Energy Assessment," a landmark study compiled by the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis.
Four commercial GTL plants have become operational over the last 20 years: Mossel Bay in South Africa (1992), Bintulu in Malaysia (1993), Oryx at in Qatar (2007) and Pearl also in Qatar (2011-14).
Combined capacity will be almost 225,000 barrels per day once Shell's Pearl project is fully operational (mostly diesel with smaller quantities of naphtha, lubricants and waxes).
South Africa's Sasol (Mossel Bay and Oryx) and Royal Dutch Shell (Bintulu and Pearl) dominate the market, though other companies including BP, Chevron and Exxon have proposed projects or built demonstration facilities over the last decade.
Shell is currently expanding Pearl and Sasol is working with Chevron and the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation to finish a GTL plant on the Escravos River in Nigeria.
Escravos, which is a copy of Oryx, will convert about 8.5 million cubic meters per day of gas, currently flared, into 22,000 barrels per day of diesel and 11,000 barrels of naphtha.
Both Shell and Sasol are reportedly considering projects on the coast of Louisiana in the US. Sasol has plans to expand its production in South Africa and to build new plants in Uzbekistan and Canada. But even the two market leaders have hesitated to make firm commitments to new projects.
Other major oil and gas producers have either avoided GTL altogether, or abandoned projects early. Exxon Mobil, Conoco and Trinidad have all canceled projects in the last decade. BP produced 300 barrels per day of synthetic crude oil at a test facility between 2002 and 2009 but has not chosen to build a full-scale plant.
The case for a big expansion of GTL production appears compelling. Nearly 40 percent of the world's natural gas reserves are too far from consuming centers to be economically delivered via pipelines: GTL, LNG or CNG may be the only way to exploit them.
GTL plants can unlock value by converting plentiful and cheap gas into scarce and valuable liquids. GTL yields lots of diesel (70 percent) rather than gasoline (25 percent), which could help bridge the worldwide shortage of middle distillates.
GTL burns cleanly (it contains almost zero sulphur) and engine performance is better than for diesel from a conventional refinery (GTL diesel has a cetane number of 70 compared with 40 for refinery output). It also avoids the expense of fitting and operating energy-intensive hydro-desulphurization units to conventional refineries.
Together with LNG, GTL is the only way to reduce wasteful venting and flaring of stranded natural gas from oil wells in countries like Nigeria, Russia, Iran and Iraq.
GTL plants are currently about 60-65 percent energy efficient. Their carbon efficiency is 75-80 percent. But projected improvements over the next decade could push energy efficiency over 70 percent, and carbon efficiency to 90 percent, comparable to conventional refining.
Escalating costs have done much to undermine GTL. The technology is relatively mature. But many developers have opted for very large-scale plants in a bid to maximize economies of scale.
GTL plants have had to compete for scarce engineering talent and raw materials such as high-strength corrosion resistant steels with the enormous number of LNG projects launched over the last ten years.
The result has been enormous pressure on the relatively scarce engineering companies and suppliers capable of delivering advanced GTL plants on this sort of scale.
In much-cited 2005 report, Professor Michael Economides of the University of Houston, put capital costs for a 65,000 barrel per day GTL plant at about 25,000 per barrel per day ("The Economics of Gas to Liquids Compared to Liquefied Natural Gas").
But following cost overruns, Shell's Pearl project ended up costing 18 billion, or about 110,000 per barrel per day for a 140,000 barrel per day plant. The Sasol-Chevron Escravos project has seen even worse cost inflation, and will likely end up costing at least 180,000 per barrel per day for 33,000 barrel per day of output.
"Construction delays are chronic. Costs escalate as the giant projects create their own economic weather for engineering, labor, steel, shipping and other services," explains Arctic Gas, which coordinates gas transport projects in Alaska for the US federal government ("Can gas to liquids technology get traction?" June 2012).
Escalating costs are only one aspect of a wider issue. "The challenge for gas to liquid technology is not high cost, it is high risk," according to the US Department of Energy's Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA-E).
GTL projects have to cope with multiple risks simultaneously: price changes in both the feedstock and product markets, construction costs, cost of catalyst, and how big a plant to build.
ARPA-E found the biggest risk was not the cost of gas, or even construction, but the realized price for the products when the project comes onstream (which explains why Pearl has been successful despite being wildly over-budget).
It takes so long to develop a large-scale GTL plant there is no guarantee the configuration of gas and diesel prices which underpinned the original investment decision will still prevail when it eventually enters into service.
"Progress has been stymied by the astronomical cost of building GTL plants, and the career risk facing chief executives who undertake such investments, as well as by oil prices that have swung between rock bottom and sky high," Arctic Gas observed.
ARPA-E highlights the tremendous swing in oil prices from under 40 per barrel to more than 110 between 2000 and 2011, the typical timeframe for developing and building a GTL project. Long delays and high costs give rise to enormous market-timing risks ("Gas to liquid technology" February 2012).
The solution may be to think smaller. Process engineers generally prefer bigger plants because costs go up in line with the surface area while revenues go up faster in line with volume. The Sasol-Chevron GTL reactor vessel is enormous.
In Shell's two 1200-ton reactor vessels at Pearl "the surface of the cobalt catalyst is so vast that if it were spread out horizontally it would encompass an area almost 18 times greater than Qatar itself," Arctic Gas says.
Smaller scale plants would be quicker to build, more responsive to changing market conditions, and a lot less risky. Building lots of small plants rather than a few big ones would also maximize the opportunity to reduce costs through learning effects.
WorldGTL and CompactGTL are already developing small-scale modular systems for offshore platforms and associated gas production. Petrobras is piloting a micro-reactor based GTL system developed by CompactGTL for some of its offshore oil installations.
If GTL is ever to contribute a significant fraction of diesel demand, developers will have to be convinced the divergence of gas and oil prices will be sustained in the long-term, and find ways to manage project risk more effectively. In the meantime, the brightest outlook may be for smaller-scale plants that can be developed more quickly with less risk.
(The author is a Reuters market analyst.
The views expressed are his own.)
MENA News Headlines
|Mar 11 2014||Egypt doctor faces trial over fatal female genital mutilation ,AFP|
(MENAFN - AFP) A doctor in Egypt will face trial for performing a female circumcision operation that killed a teenage girl, a judicial official said on Tuesday.
The 14-year-old girl's father who ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Al Hilal Bank - Kazakhstan shares banking expertise at TradeInvest Central Asia forum ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) Al Hilal Bank â€“ Kazakhstan, the first Islamic bank in Kazakhstan, yesterday (Monday, March 10, 2014) joined a panel discussion on business opportunities in Central Asia at the Trade ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Africa Finance Corporation (AFC) Hosts Inaugural Summit to Address the Scale of Africas Infrastructure Requirements and Investment Deficit
|(MENAFN Press) The Africa Finance Corporation (AFC) (http://www.africafc.org), an African-led multilateral development financial institution whose mission is to improve African economies by ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Dubai Exports invites local firms to capitalise on opportunities in fast-growing Central Asia ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) Dubai Exports, the export promotion agency of the Department of Economic Development (DED) â€“ Government of Dubai, today hosted a networking seminar in partnership with the Trade and ...|
|Mar 11 2014||7 companies bid for Oman airport contract ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Seven construction companies are bidding for the Package-3 contract of the new Sohar regional airport in Oman, Arabian Business reported.
Package-3 includes the construction of a ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Emirates REIT to raise USD135m in IPO ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) The first real estate investment trust in the UAE, Emirates REIT, said that it plans to raise at least USD135 million through an initial public offering of shares, Arabian Business ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Saudi Aramco plans to increase natural gas output ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Saudi Aramco announced its plan to produce 200 million cubic feet per day (cfd) of unconventional natural gas by 2018, Arabian Business reported.
An industry source said that the firm's ...|
|Mar 11 2014||South American 'mate' tea a long-time Lebanese hit ,AFP|
(MENAFN - AFP) Steam rises from a gourd filled with yerba mate as Wissam al-Halabi takes a sip, seated on a Lebanese mountain slope where the South American drink has become a local tradition.
|Mar 11 2014||Tanker escapes to sea with cargo of Libyan rebel oil ,AFP|
(MENAFN - AFP) A North Korean-flagged tanker laden with oil from a rebel-held terminal in eastern Libya slipped the warships deployed to intercept it and escaped to sea on Tuesday, MPs said.
|Mar 11 2014||D&S wins USD9.5m Dubai Airport project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Drake & Scull Rail, a subsidiary of Drake & Scull International PJSC (DSI) announced that it won a USD9.5 million contract for a new airport passenger movement system at the Dubai ...|
|Mar 11 2014||DDC, Starcare sign USD18m hospital deal in Duqm ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman's Duqm Development Company (DDC) and Starcare Hospital have signed an agreement for the construction of a hospital at Duqm, Times of Oman reported.
The project, at an estimated cost ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Oman to award USD65 b projects the next five years ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) According to an expert, Oman is going to award engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contracts worth USD65 billion in the next five years, Times of Oman reported.
These projects ...|
|Mar 11 2014||New WaveLogic Photonics Capabilities from Ciena Give Service Providers Greater Visibility, Control and Automation ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) CienaÂ® Corporation, the network specialist, today unveiled WaveLogic Photonics, new line intelligence capabilities that significantly improve visibility, control and programmability ...|
|Mar 11 2014||SAMENA Councils Beyond Connectivity to highlight four-pillar approach for telecom operators which can boost economic growthsustainable development ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) The South Asia, Middle East, North Africa region's SAMENA Telecommunication Council has announced today its Beyond Connectivity 2014 conference themed "Fostering Economic Growth: ...|
|Mar 11 2014||ZOTAC Launches New ZBOX E-Series Gaming and ZBOX nano AQ02 Series Palm-Sized mini-PCs ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) ZOTAC International, a global innovator and manufacturer of graphics cards, mainboards and mini-PCs, today starts CeBIT 2014 with a pair of new ZBOX E-series gaming mini-PCs and the ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Tunis Financial Harbour Signs the Appointment of Soroubat to Commence Development ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) Tunis Bay Project Company (TBPC), announced at a press conference held in Tunisia the appointment of Soroubat, a leading Tunisian contractor, for the development of the infrastructure ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Indulge in special Mothers Day treats at Concorde ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) Concorde Hotel Fujairah lets you celebrate the special Day for Mums with its exclusive dining and spa promotions for the entire month of March.
Relish a month-long gastronomic feast ...|
|Mar 11 2014||NestlÃ© Transparent on commitments ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) NestlÃ©'s efforts to meet a series of commitments in areas where the company engages with society are detailed in a new report, NestlÃ© in Society 2013.
The 35 pledges cover ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Al Basel Group launches Amani Investments ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) The Al Basel Group of Companies has revealed the launch of Amani Investments, the conglomerate's latest addition to its diverse portfolio of business interests. Established to be the ...|
|Mar 11 2014||Commercial aviation is a key pillar of the U.S.-U.A.E. relationship ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) Record trade numbers between the U.S. and U.A.E. totaled $26.9 billion in 2013, with commercial aviation partnerships playing a central role in that success, according to the ...|