MENAFN - Arab News
Journalism ethics and feeding business bubbles
(MENAFN - Arab News) I AM sure many were surprised, as I was, when a leading Saudi newspaper published on its first page last week a "report" on accomplishments of a local company. The report was little more than an advertisement in the guise of an impartial report. There was no critical or evaluative input of any kind.
This business report was placed on the top of page one, high above the fold, next to news about King Abullah's health, but higher on the page than Gaza news and a report on the trial of terrorism suspects in Riyadh. Coincidently, the report was placed on the same space that this company's proper advertisements had occupied in previous weeks.
This incident was only the most glaring recent example of blurring the lines between advertising and impartial reporting. It used to be most noticeable in business pages, but now it is creeping to the front page. It is also part of a larger problem of uncritical business reporting, which takes several manifestations and with possibly disastrous consequences for the profession, the economy and consumers of news.
There is of course the common practice of rewriting press releases issued by companies, with no independent commentary.
More insidious, however, is publishing stories that take the guise of an independent investigative report, but in fact contains only partial analysis representing a particular business' point of view. Earlier this month, I wrote about how food importers and retailers have tried to justify raising their prices in Saudi Arabia by creating an impression that international food prices had risen. They were aided by some reports in the local press supporting that point of view. It worked, as I pointed out in that essay ("Food prices drop globally but rise in local markets!" Arab News, Nov. 11, 2012): While food prices declined by 8 percent this year, food prices have risen in Saudi Arabia by over 5 percent, despite the fact that most food items sold in Saudi Arabia are imported.
In another example last year, a leading newspaper published a detailed report supporting higher prices for clothes in Saudi Arabia, because cotton prices had risen internationally, it asserted. The report cited supporting statements, predictably, from clothing wholesalers and retailers. No officials were interviewed, nor consumer representatives, as an impartial report would have done. The truth was, as we know, international cotton prices declined dramatically last year, just the opposite of what the report claimed.
The real estate sector was hit hard by the global crisis, both in our region and across the world. However, while real estate developers in the United States and Europe were on the defensive, some local developers took the opposite approach, aggressively marketing their new big projects.
Regrettably, they were aided by uncritical reporting. One TV network put together a multipart program, relying heavily on experts from one real estate developer who was also its main sponsor. The whole series served as a disguised advertisement.
Of course, there has always been tension between journalism ethics and business reporting, probably more than any other kind of reporting. There are many temptations, of course, that could sway reporters, even when they do not mean to. There is also the matter of expertise. New business practices, whether in real estate, banking or financial instruments are not easy to decipher and dissect, causing journalists to rely heavily on their developers for evaluation.
However, the global financial crisis revealed many unethical press practices around the world, when it came to business matters. Those revelations led to closer scrutiny of business reporting, but also to moves in many quarters to implement more rigorous ethics standards. Unfortunately, this soul searching has yet to reach our local press.
After the collapse of the real estate markets in the United States and Europe, many discovered that business journalism had in fact fed the real estate bubble. True, there were doubting voices that warned about inflated prices and shady lending practices, but most reports were of the cheerleading type.
Uncritical reporting about the financial industry overlooked the financial bubble as well. Readers got accustomed to good news that they forgot about the great risks implicit in the new financial instruments.
All of this has led to consistent calls for stronger ethical standards for business reporting, to be used for self-policing by reporters, analysts and news organizations.
Several useful codes have been developed over the years, including: Dow Jones Code of Ethics, Thomson Reuters Code of Ethics, American Business Media Code of Ethics, American Society of Business Publication Editors Code of Preferred Editorial Practices, Associated Press Statement of News Values and Principles, Society of American Business Editors and Writers Code of Ethics and the BusinessWeek Code of Ethics.
However, a code of ethics is of no use if it is not followed. News organizations should rigorously require their reporters and their columnists to abide by the code of ethics it chooses. However, if news organizations are unwilling or incapable of performing this task, peer scrutiny by professional organization should do that.
So far, in our region at least, peer organizations have largely stood silently by. News organizations are rarely if ever taken to task for shoddy business reporting.
Until there is a change, it is up to consumers of business news to try to implement codes of ethics.
MENA News Headlines
|Mar 9 2014||Libya separatists load NKorea oil ship and ignore warning ,AFP|
(MENAFN - AFP) Libyan separatists loaded oil onto a North Korean tanker for a second consecutive day on Sunday, ignoring the central government's threats of military action, an industry official ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Al Hamra launches USD272 m project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE's Al Hamra Real Estate Development has announced the opening of the USD 272 million Falcon Island project in Ras Al Khaimah, according to Khaleej Times.
The new project aims to ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman aims to increase non-oil exports by 15 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman is aiming to increase the value of its non-oil exports by 15 percent this year, Times of Oman reported.
The Director of Export Development at Ithraa said that Oman's exports of ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman's government revenue drops 7.9 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman's National Centre for Statistics and Information (NCSI) said that the country's government revenues dropped 7.9 percent in January, Times of Oman reported.
The NCSI said that ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman's foreign trade up 9.1 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Statistics released by the Omani National Centre for Statistics and Information (NCSI) show an increase in the Sultanate's foreign trade, Times of Oman reported.
The data show that the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Dubai-based Deyaar plans USD245m residential, hotel project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based Deyaar Development announced its plan to build a residential and hotel project in Dubai, Arabian Business reported.
The project, at a total cost of USD245 million, will consist ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Jumbo plans expansion ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based retail electronics giant Jumbo Group announced that it plans to expand its engineering and B2B businesses as well as its retail footprint in the GCC, India and Iran, Arabian ...|
|Mar 9 2014||New fashion company plans IPO in Dubai ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) A retailing company still being formed is planning for its first initial public offering (IPO) on Dubai's main stock market in five years, Arabian Business reported.
The company will ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's du signs agreement with international telecom companies ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) du, the Middle East"s fastest growing telecom service provider, has joined an international consortium that includes several telecom companies to build South East Asia - Middle East -Western ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's RTA wins USD27 m contract ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE's Board of Directors of the Roads & Transport Authority (RTA) has won a contract to construct and collector internal roads at Al Barsha South 1 and Al Barsha South 2, according to the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Dubai's Emirates to sign off USD76 b deal with Boeing ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Dubai"s Emirates said it will cancel its USD76 billion purchase of Boeing 777X wide-body planes for reasons, such as performance guarantees, according to Arabian Business.
The order ...|
|Mar 9 2014||La Liga Preview: Real Madrid v Levante ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Carlo Ancelotti's side rescued a 3-2 win at Estadi Ciutat de Valencia in October with stoppage-time goals from Alvaro Morata and Cristiano Ronaldo.
They will enter this weekend's ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Steyn, Johnson absent for T20 series ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Mitchell Johnson has been rested for the three-match series, returning to Australia ahead of the World Twenty20 in Bangladesh.
Dale Steyn battled through South Africa's third Test ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Lee, Son progress to Birmingham last four ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Malaysia's Lee thrashed Japan's Kento Momota 21-14 21-18 in their quarter-finals at the National Indoor Arena in Birmingham.
He will face Son Wan Ho in the last four after the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Copa Libertadores Preview: Atletico Mineiro, Velez Sarsfield near progression ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Both teams have claimed two wins from as many games in their groups and a third € halfway through the stage € would set them up nicely.
Mineiro have edged their way to the top of ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Davids: Del Piero should delay coaching plans ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora)
The Sydney FC star, 39, is nearing the end of his career and is yet to re-sign with the A-League club, having been linked with another move to Asia.
Davids, who played alongside ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Blanc confirms Cavani will miss Bastia trip ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora)Cavani returned to Uruguay earlier in the week for personal reasons and will not be back in time for Saturday's match.
The 27-year-old has scored 14 goals in 22 league appearances ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Barca are not in decline, Xavi insists ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Barca secured three La Liga titles, two Copa del Rey medals and twice won the UEFA Champions League under the stewardship of former coach Pep Guardiola,
Tito Vilanova carried on ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Majid Al Futtaim sign agreement with HCT ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based retail giant Majid Al Futtaim and Higher Colleges of Technology (HCT) have signed an agreement to launch a retail academy and industry consortium, according to Arabian ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Northampton book Anglo-Welsh Cup final spot ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) George Pisi was the star of the show for the 2010 winners at Franklin's Gardens as he completed a hat-trick in the second half to complete a comfortable victory.
Saracens struggled ...|