Quotes: US MENA   Enter Symbol: NewsLetter: Search: advanced

Brahimi belongs to a generation of failure  Join our daily free Newsletter

MENAFN - Arab News - 30/10/2012

No. of Ratings : 0
Add to Mixx!


 


(MENAFN - Arab News) No one knows why did Lakhdar Brahimi accept the task to find a solution to the Syrian crisis. Does he himself know why?

Brahimi immediately said after accepting the assignment in an interview with BBC that he is fully aware that his mission is almost impossible.

Why did he accept the task then? His answer was: "For the sake of trying, I don't have the right to refuse."

When asked if he has a solution, or a vision to try. He said no. It is important to note that his mission came after the hard failure of Kofi Annan and Brahimi knew he would have to start from the scratch.

And he almost started from the scratch. Meanwhile, the death toll in Syria reached more than 20,000 people. Is this figure equivalent to zero? As if it didn't cross Barhimi's mind that with this mission of his, he is in a sense granting the Syrian regime an extra time to go on with its military solution. And he is providing a political cover to the chilling murders in Syria no matter who is committing them.

It has been more than three months since the start of his mission and it is also the most bloody and destructive period since the beginning of the Syrian uprising. Did Brahimi consider the issue from this point of view? Until now, his mission was just a means to buy time, a means that international and regional forces used, including the Syrian regime, in absence of any clear understanding of a possible solution that can protect their interests and suit their calculations.

There is a bewildering question in Brahimi's mission. Does he actually think that he could reach a political solution with Syrian regime, a solution that can provide a transitional phase? Does he think a regime that uses its heavy killing machines, airplanes and some of the prohibited weapons against its people will really be interested in a political solution? In normal cases, when a political crisis emerges between a ruling system and its people, the political solution is their first choice. But in Syria's case, the regime started with the military solution from the first day of the uprising.

The story of Daraa children is well known in this regard. No doubt that Brahimi is well aware of this story and the facts surrounding it more than anybody else.

During the second day of the uprising, the first martyr fell down. This was in the middle of last March, more than five months later, the regime started to describe the protesters as militants and terrorist groups. And now, the victims of the regime from all walks of life reached hundreds of thousands. If we add the category of refugees to this, the figure could reach a million.
Does Brahimi believe that such a regime could really think of a political solution that leads to a transitional phase? A transitional phase means that a different system should replace the old one, with a leadership chosen by the free will of its people, is it possible that the Syrian regime could accept this solution after it has gone this far, too far indeed, in spilling the blood of its people?

Anyone who thinks of such a solution does not start arresting children and does not destroy neighborhoods inhabited by people.

The Syrian regime is a hostage to a closed sectarian coalition at local and regional levels. It doesn't trust anybody outside this coalition, Syrians or otherwise. It came to power by violence and made violence its primary means to deal with its people and its neighbors for more than 40 years. It resorted to bloodletting and violence in Hama uprising in 1982 and in the current uprising as well. The Syrian regime killed Syrian people only, and so far it has killed more Syrians, in fact, the double than those including Syrians, Palestinians and Lebanese killed by the Israel Defense Forces.

The history and nature of the system never accommodated any political process in Syria. It didn't get involved in any real political dialogue, except with Americans and Israelis, because its leadership knows well enough what Americans and Israelis have. The political scope in Syria, as well as in many Arab countries, doesn't go beyond the president's palace, not even beyond the president's office in the palace. So, what political solution does Brahimi speak about?

Sometimes it is said that Brahimi is thinking about a sectarian Syrian solution. Personally, I know nothing about this. Any person thinks this way doesn't know Syria well. Its demographic composition is very different from that of Lebanon. It cannot accommodate such an agreement. Any agreement modeled on the Taif agreement means the division of Syria. Is this what Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov meant when he said last week that Assad is the protector of minorities in Syria? That is, if the opposition insisted on the overthrow of the regime, Assad may separate himself with minorities close to Alawites areas in order to protect them.

Here may come a new Sykes-Picot for Syria, but from the Russian and Iranian gates. But at least most Syrians will not approve this solution.
It seems that Brahimi didn't think much of the Syrian people. The photo of him exchanging a lively laughing talk with the Syrian president the day after the Beirut bombings means that the president himself used him to send a media message without him actually noticing that.

The scene in Syria is massive and imposing. People die every day there, so what are the reasons for a laughing talk with a president whose forces are bombing cites and neighborhoods?

The only thing that seems to govern Brahimi thinking, his movements, choices and statements is the attitudes and interests of political systems. He must satisfy all states. His only craftsmanship in this context is creating a space for him between the attitudes and interests of all these states, with all its contradictions.

The members of the Security Council unanimously demanded to ensure the success of his mission. Because his mission is impossible - as he himself described it - the responsibility of achieving this consensus has become his own, not any of these countries. He should not say anything when he makes a statement and should not take an important stance no matter how much blood is being spilled in Syria. He should not express any opinions that would upset any country, then his mission would stop or end completely.

Brahimi was born on Jan. 1, 1934. The history of his earlier political missions suggests that he belongs to a generation of failure in almost everything: In politics, in wars, both inside and outside. Also a failure in building a state and a nation that recognizes humanity of its citizens, their dignity and rights. This generation succeeded only in one thing: Building a political system instead of a state, so that everything takes off from there.

This doesn't mean that Brahimi in person is a political failure. He is not. But in his mission in Syria, he started from the same system and ended there. This mission is turning out to be his Achilles' heel. He failed in Iraq, only partially succeeded in Lebanon, and achieved a half success in Afghanistan. His mission's failure looms large in Syria even before he starts.

Brahimi's professional record is filled with positions and tasks. He was a representative of the Algerian National Liberation Front during the 1950s and 1960s. Then he became minister for foreign affairs of Algeria between 1991 and 1993. This means that he knows the Arab regimes, knows their nature, and knows how to deal with them. Therefore, he knows the Syrian regime well. What does his knowledge say about the relationship of this regime with its people? How would this regime deal with a popular uprising? Does he personally believe this regime when it says that it agrees to a truce for Eid Al-Adha?

Furthermore, Brahimi is a member of many international organizations on the issue of good governance. Does he believe that the Syrian regime is interested in the issue of good governance? It is not required of Brahimi to make the trial of the Syrian system a part of his mission. This matter is outside the main subject here. But he is required to employ his political experience, his legal background and his knowledge of the Arab reality to expose the situation in Syria as he sees it, in full transparency and honesty. Unveiling the truth helps a great deal in reaching a solution, more than this cold diplomacy of the United Nations, more than this tasteless, odorless diplomacy that the Arab League.

Brahimi is required to be committed literally to what he frequently repeated, that his primary and final objective are the Syrian people, and the rights of these people. This, at least, may compensate the political failure of his mission.

 






  MENA News Headlines
Apr 23 2014Omantel launches service package for youth ,MENAFN
(MENAFN) Omantel announced launching 'Ozone' plan, a new package designed especially for the youth. This comes with the company"s constant efforts to enhance the communication needs of its customers, ...

Apr 23 2014Dh154 billion for Arabtec projects ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Arabtec will spend dh140 billion on building one million low-cost houses in egypt and dh14 billion on five mixed-use residential projects in abu dhabi and dubai its chief ...

Apr 23 2014?Titli? makers excited about Cannes selection ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) The movie about the badlands of delhi?s dystopic underbelly will be in competition as part of the un certain regard section of the 67th cannes film gala to be held may ...

Apr 23 2014Saudi- Yaroub Bashraheel: In search of peace ... underwater ,Arab News
(MENAFN - Arab News) You've heard of diving snorkeling and other water activities but rarely has anyone heard of free-diving. it's a form of diving underwater without the aid of any breathing ...

Apr 23 2014Saudi- Schneider highlights intelligent health care solutions at forum ,Arab News
(MENAFN - Arab News) Schneider electric a global specialist in energy management is set to showcase its leadership in intelligent health care solutions at the second saudi forum for planning and ...

Apr 23 2014Saudi- Divorcees can seek housing ,Arab News
(MENAFN - Arab News) The kingdom will accept applications from saudi divorced women and widows for financial and housing support said justice minister muhammad al-issa.al-issa called on applicants ...

Apr 23 2014Saudi- New passport office opens at Red Sea Mall ,Arab News
(MENAFN - Arab News) The passport department has opened a new office for citizens and residents at the red sea mall.gen. abdul rahman bin abdullah al-tuwairki deputy director general of the ...

Apr 23 2014Kowait- Police deportation powers curbed ,Arab Times
(MENAFN - Arab Times) Kuwait city april 3 (afp): kuwaiti police will no longer be able to deport expatriates without interior ministry approval under new rules published thursday after officers ...

Apr 23 2014Kowait- Amiri Diwan urges all off tape case ,Arab Times
(MENAFN - Arab Times)  kuwait city april 9 (agencies): the amiri diwan has called on everybody to steer clear of the controversial tape issue and let the public prosecution take the necessary ...

Apr 23 2014Saudi Savola Group revenue up 43 pct in Q1 ,MENAFN
(MENAFN) Saudi Arabia's Savola Group registered a 43 percent increase in profits in the first quarter, well over expectations of analysts, Arabian Business reported. According to a statement to ...

Apr 23 2014Dewa and GE explore collaboration opportunities ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Saeed mohammed al tayer managing director and chief executive officer of the dubai electricity and water authority (dewa) recently received a ge delegation to explore ...

Apr 23 2014Local international companies come out in force ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Cityscape abu dhabi has started showing stronger interest from property developers who have showcased their upcoming projects. the three-day realty show was opened by ...

Apr 23 2014Tamouh steps up activity on projects ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Abu dhabi-based real-estate developer tamouh has scaled up construction activity on all of its announced reem island projects to meet the rising demand for prime spaces in ...

Apr 23 2014Kowait- New hospital to be ready by 2014 end ,Arab Times
(MENAFN - Arab Times) Kuwait city jan 14 (kuna): director of the 'mega projects 3' group at kuwait oil company (koc) yaqoub dashti said on tuesday that the new ahmadi hospital would be ready to ...

Apr 23 2014Seven tied for the lead in chess championships ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Former champion sukandar grabs lead of asian continental women?s chess. former asian women’s champion wgm irene sukandar of indonesia (left) beat wim ni shiqun ...

Apr 23 2014ADCB NIC in Dh950 million deal ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Abu dhabi commercial bank or adcb this week inked a dh950 million term facility to provide national investment corporation or nic the developer of the breakwater area in ...

Apr 23 2014Gitex Shopper Spring 2014 to open doors today ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Gitex shopper spring 2014 is set to open doors today with best bargains on latest tech products along with millions of dirhams worth of prizes during the four-day ...

Apr 23 2014Here?s your chance to share screen space with SRK ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Groupon india has joined hands with srk?s red chillies entertainment to give fans a chance to feature with the superstar in his upcoming film ?happy new year?. if you ...

Apr 23 2014Lebanon sends trapped citizens aid ,Arab News
(MENAFN - Arab News) Ras al-harf: lebanese authorities on tuesday sent a rare aid convoy to the town of tufeil an island of lebanese territory inside syria where thousands have become trapped in ...

Apr 23 2014Two suspects held for robbing pedestrians in Sharjah ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) The sharjah police on tuesday arrested two stateless citizens for allegedly robbing many persons posing as criminal investigation department (cid) officers. the suspects ...

more...


 






Google

 
 

Middle East North Africa - Financial Network

MENAFN News Market Data Countries Tools Section  
 

Middle East North Africa - Financial Network
Arabic MENAFN

Main News
News By Industry
News By Country
Marketwatch News
UPI News
Comtex News

IPO News
Islamic Finance News
Private Equity News

How-To Guides
Technology Section

Travel Section

Search News

Market Indices
Quotes & Charts

Global Indices
Arab Indices

US Markets Details

Commodoties

Oil & Energy

Currencies Cross Rates
Currencies Updates
Currency Converter

USA Stocks
Arab Stocks
 

Algeria 
Bahrain 
Egypt 
Iraq
Jordan 
Kuwait 
Lebanon
Morocco 
Oman 
Palestine
Qatar 
Saudi Arabia 
Syria
Tunisia 
UAE 
Yemen

Weather
Investment Game
Economic Calendar
Financial Glossary

My MENAFN
Portfolio Tracker

Voting

Financial Calculators

RSS Feeds [XML]

Corporate Monitor

Events

Real Estate
Submit Your Property

Arab Research
Buy a Research

Press Releases
Submit your PR

Join Newsletters


 
© 2000 menafn.com All Rights Reserved.  Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Advertise | About MENAFN | Career Opportunities | Feedback | Help