MENAFN - Arab News
Nuclear-free Middle East faces an arduous road
(MENAFN - Arab News) A VEIL of silence and secrecy has shrouded the fate of a conference on the establishment of a Middle East zone free of nuclear weapons and all other weapons of mass destruction in 2012, since the UN announced on Oct. 14, 2011 that Finland will host it. The veil slowly lifting now corresponds to the "wall of silence" in Israel, which Israeli anti-nuke activist Sharon Dolev is persistently trying to break - with some success.
Knowledgeable sources in Berlin, London and Helsinki are convinced that the conference will indeed take place - from Dec. 14 to 16 with seasoned Finnish diplomat and politician Jaakko Laajava as facilitator. However, hardly anyone appears to be particularly enthusiastic about it.
In fact, as Kate Hudson, general secretary of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (CND) and a leading anti-nuclear and anti-war campaigner says, "many will see this proposal as a pipedream." She adds: "There are of course significant obstacles to overcome before this conference can
succeed, but certainly, the biggest threat to the region would be failure."
Reporting about obstacles to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) preparatory committee meeting early May 2012 in Vienna, Laajava said that although he had conducted more than 100 meetings - both inside and outside the region - he had yet to secure an agreement from all relevant states on participation.
"News of Laajava's no-news statement was met with another round of eye-rolling and finger-pointing: The likely holdouts are Israel and Iran, with a major question mark hanging over Syrian participation," wrote Martin B. Malin in the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists.
But Malin - who is the executive director of the Project on Managing the Atom at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government - is nevertheless optimistic that Israel may come to see as the least unpalatable option negotiations with its neighbors to establish rules for limiting the possession of WMD (weapons of mass destruction) across the region, eventually putting its own capabilities on the negotiating table.
"Discussing a WMD-free zone would allow Israel to prolong its nuclear weapons monopoly with the fewest challenges for an interim period, while negotiating the terms of a transition to a nuclear and WMD free Middle East. It can also use a forum on regional arms control as a venue to raise its concerns about proliferation elsewhere in the region," avers Malin.
In his view, Iran too has important security interests in pursuing a WMD-free zone. Because Tehran has a long-term strategic interest in denuclearizing Israel, and, "odious as it might seem to Iran's leaders, direct negotiations with Israel on regional security and a WMD ban are the only way to do that."
Facilitator Laajava has formally asked Iran to participate in the planned conference. With the planned dates fast approaching, the conference facilitator and civil society organizations are faced with a huge task to persuade key participants that, as Hudson says, nuclear weapons-free zones (NWFZs) are highly successful forms of collective security across large parts of the world. Currently, 115 states and 18 other territories belong to five regional treaties, covering a majority of the earth's surface, including almost the entire southern hemisphere.
The establishment of such a zone in the Middle East was first proposed in 1974 by Iran, now being ostracized for its alleged nuke development program. Egypt extended the proposal in 1990 to include other WMD (weapons of mass destruction), reflecting the serious concern around chemical and biological warfare in the region. A resolution on achieving a WMD-free zone was adopted at the 1995 Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) Review Conference.
Fifteen years later, the 2010 NPT Review Conference identified five steps necessary toward the goal of establishing a WMD-free zone in the Middle East, including convening a regional conference in 2012 and appointing a facilitator.
"Failure to move forward in establishing a WMD-free zone will in fact mean that the stakes will remain higher in any potential conflict. And the stakes are always a human cost," cautions CND's Hudson. Voicing general concern, the Egyptian Foreign Ministry says in a document submitted in May 2012 to the planning committee of the NPT Review Conference in 2015 that the Arab League sees the conference in Finland as an important crossroad with regard to its nuclear policies. It believes that if realistic and practical steps toward WMD disarmament cannot be agreed upon, then nuclear proliferation will become a dangerous reality across the region. The international community should therefore do all it can to avert this.
There is a pressing need for open discussions about security concerns and weapons capacity, which will be vital to the success of WMD-free zone in the Middle East: and it begins with opening channels of communication which are the building blocks of peace and genuine security.
This is what Dolev has been doing with a handful of activists under the umbrella of the Greenpeace and in cooperation, among others, with the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN).
In the face of uncertainty about Israeli participation in the conference, the evolution of the Treaty of Tlatelolco may in fact serve as a role model for the Middle East conference in Finland, suggests Dolev during a visit to Berlin.
The possibility is not ruled out that like Argentina, to begin with Israel (and Iran) stay away from signing any agreement. But the conference could trigger landmark cooperation and negotiations which would be essential in establishing a WMD-free zone would be positive for intra-regional relations.
"And while states may be cautious in their approach, if they believe that this can be a serious framework for peaceful coexistence then of course they would be supportive. Such caution can be gradually turned to confidence, through robust and transparent verification measures, as well as binding mechanisms with teeth," says Hudson.
Though Israelis are open to debate, they not only tend to consider the nuclear question taboo but also rather complex for expressing dissenting opinions. Subsequently, most people accept that only top acting political and military leaders assume that right, only in closed forums.
"Any relevant information in Hebrew is rare; information in English is abundant but arduous to analyze," says journalist Pierre Klochendler. "The absence of discussion stems also from the fact that, since the inception of its own nuclear program in the late 1950s, Israel has officially stuck to a policy of 'ambiguity': it 'won't be the first country to introduce nuclear weapons in the region" is the official posture.
Ambiguity, therefore, means that the international community should continue to ignore Dimona, believed to be the centre of the Israeli nuclear program, and focus solely on Natanz, allegedly the nerve center of the Iranian nuclear program.
Israeli government officials praise "ambiguity" as it enhances Israel's security almost as much as WMD. Assuming such a policy is necessary, anti-nuclear activists propose a debate which would respect the constraints of not exposing Israel's nuclear capability. Such discussion would strengthen the democratic character of their society.
"It's still possible, even obligatory, to hold serious discussions about the need for nuclear weapons, the dangers they present regionally and globally, and the various possibilities for disarmament," says Dolev.
The sense of creativity which permeates the activities of Dolev and her supports is reflected also in the visit of four survivors of the Hiroshima nuclear bomb massacre (the Hibakusha) to Israel and their meetings with broad sections of the society, including survivors of the holocaust. Such meetings drew attention to the catastrophic nature of nuclear arsenal.
Dolev's actions are guided by the underlying conviction that "Israel's practice of hiding in the bunker of ambiguity is perceived as a threat and not as a gesture of nonviolence or as an absence of an intended threat."
On the other hand, an anti-nuclear movement in Israel that would bring the question of the country's nuclear policy to national and global media attention would reveal a more open Israel, an Israel with which one can talk and, moreover, an Israel with a democratic society that is not monolithic, where different opinions exist and can be expressed, maintains Dolev.
- The article was written for InDepthNews.
MENA News Headlines
|Mar 9 2014||Libya separatists load NKorea oil ship and ignore warning ,AFP|
(MENAFN - AFP) Libyan separatists loaded oil onto a North Korean tanker for a second consecutive day on Sunday, ignoring the central government's threats of military action, an industry official ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Al Hamra launches USD272 m project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE's Al Hamra Real Estate Development has announced the opening of the USD 272 million Falcon Island project in Ras Al Khaimah, according to Khaleej Times.
The new project aims to ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman aims to increase non-oil exports by 15 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman is aiming to increase the value of its non-oil exports by 15 percent this year, Times of Oman reported.
The Director of Export Development at Ithraa said that Oman's exports of ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman's government revenue drops 7.9 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman's National Centre for Statistics and Information (NCSI) said that the country's government revenues dropped 7.9 percent in January, Times of Oman reported.
The NCSI said that ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Oman's foreign trade up 9.1 percent ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Statistics released by the Omani National Centre for Statistics and Information (NCSI) show an increase in the Sultanate's foreign trade, Times of Oman reported.
The data show that the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Dubai-based Deyaar plans USD245m residential, hotel project ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based Deyaar Development announced its plan to build a residential and hotel project in Dubai, Arabian Business reported.
The project, at a total cost of USD245 million, will consist ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Jumbo plans expansion ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based retail electronics giant Jumbo Group announced that it plans to expand its engineering and B2B businesses as well as its retail footprint in the GCC, India and Iran, Arabian ...|
|Mar 9 2014||New fashion company plans IPO in Dubai ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) A retailing company still being formed is planning for its first initial public offering (IPO) on Dubai's main stock market in five years, Arabian Business reported.
The company will ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's du signs agreement with international telecom companies ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) du, the Middle East"s fastest growing telecom service provider, has joined an international consortium that includes several telecom companies to build South East Asia - Middle East -Western ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's RTA wins USD27 m contract ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE's Board of Directors of the Roads & Transport Authority (RTA) has won a contract to construct and collector internal roads at Al Barsha South 1 and Al Barsha South 2, according to the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Dubai's Emirates to sign off USD76 b deal with Boeing ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Dubai"s Emirates said it will cancel its USD76 billion purchase of Boeing 777X wide-body planes for reasons, such as performance guarantees, according to Arabian Business.
The order ...|
|Mar 9 2014||La Liga Preview: Real Madrid v Levante ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Carlo Ancelotti's side rescued a 3-2 win at Estadi Ciutat de Valencia in October with stoppage-time goals from Alvaro Morata and Cristiano Ronaldo.
They will enter this weekend's ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Steyn, Johnson absent for T20 series ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Mitchell Johnson has been rested for the three-match series, returning to Australia ahead of the World Twenty20 in Bangladesh.
Dale Steyn battled through South Africa's third Test ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Lee, Son progress to Birmingham last four ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Malaysia's Lee thrashed Japan's Kento Momota 21-14 21-18 in their quarter-finals at the National Indoor Arena in Birmingham.
He will face Son Wan Ho in the last four after the ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Copa Libertadores Preview: Atletico Mineiro, Velez Sarsfield near progression ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Both teams have claimed two wins from as many games in their groups and a third € halfway through the stage € would set them up nicely.
Mineiro have edged their way to the top of ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Davids: Del Piero should delay coaching plans ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora)
The Sydney FC star, 39, is nearing the end of his career and is yet to re-sign with the A-League club, having been linked with another move to Asia.
Davids, who played alongside ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Blanc confirms Cavani will miss Bastia trip ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora)Cavani returned to Uruguay earlier in the week for personal reasons and will not be back in time for Saturday's match.
The 27-year-old has scored 14 goals in 22 league appearances ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Barca are not in decline, Xavi insists ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) Barca secured three La Liga titles, two Copa del Rey medals and twice won the UEFA Champions League under the stewardship of former coach Pep Guardiola,
Tito Vilanova carried on ...|
|Mar 9 2014||UAE's Majid Al Futtaim sign agreement with HCT ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) UAE-based retail giant Majid Al Futtaim and Higher Colleges of Technology (HCT) have signed an agreement to launch a retail academy and industry consortium, according to Arabian ...|
|Mar 9 2014||Northampton book Anglo-Welsh Cup final spot ,Kora|
|(MENAFN - Kora) George Pisi was the star of the show for the 2010 winners at Franklin's Gardens as he completed a hat-trick in the second half to complete a comfortable victory.
Saracens struggled ...|