Quotes: US MENA   Enter Symbol: NewsLetter: Search: advanced

Freedom of speech: East and West divide  Join our daily free Newsletter

MENAFN - Arab News - 30/09/2012

No. of Ratings : 0
Add to Mixx!


(MENAFN - Arab News) JUST as diplomatic relations, based on mutual trust, are crucial to a sound global dialogue of cultures, so are interfaith relations, based on open-mindedness, equally crucial to a peaceful world.
So where does the issue of free speech come into the equation? How far do Americans need to go in order to protect their First Amendment privileges? And where do Muslims, in the Arab world and beyond, draw the line when that right appears to represent an assault on their most sacred values?
Search no farther than the forum of the General Assembly of the United Nations, where American President Barack Obama and Egyptian President Muhammad Mursi, both addressed the issue earlier this week, respectively on Tuesday and Wednesday. I quote in detail (and bear with me here) from both, the leader of the most influential nation in the world, and from the leader of the most populous country in the Arab world.
President Obama was bluntly assertive in making the American point of view clear in the wake of violent anti-American protests that followed the release of a crude online video denigrating Islam and its Prophet (peace be upon him). "(E)fforts to restrict speech can become a tool to silence critics," he said. "We do so because given the power of faith in our lives, and the passion that religious differences can inflame, the strongest weapon against hateful speech is not repression, it is more speech - the voices of tolerance that rally against bigotry and blasphemy, and lift up the values of understanding and mutual respect... (Americans) have fought and died around the globe to protect the right of all people to express their views."
President Mursi, who condemned recent outbursts of anti-American violence, nevertheless disagreed - or seemed to, at first blush - with Obama's broad analysis of the role of free speech in a free society. He said: "Egypt respects freedom of expression, freedom of expression that is not used to incite hatred against anyone. We expect from others, as they expect from us, that they respect our cultural specifics and religious references, and not seek to impose concepts or cultures that are unacceptable to us. Insults against the Prophet of Islam are not acceptable. We will not allow anyone to do this by word or deed."
So does that mean we have two irreconcilable views here, two colliding cultrual paradigms? Far from it. Both the American and the Egyptian presidents, I say, were simply climbing the same mountain from two different sides.
In Western culture, freedom of expression is considered both a sacrosanct right and a necessary function of a robust public debate. It is also recognized as a human right under Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which guarantees the individual the prerogative to hold, seek and impart opinions without interference from anyone or fear of retribution from the state. All well and good. But that does not include the right, say, to slander and libel. Above all, it does not include the right to incite violence or the right to disseminate "hate speech."
This is encoded in the laws of both the United States and several countries in the European Union. In Germany, for example, "volksverhetzung" (inciting the people) is a criminal law that bans provocative statements whose aim is to incite hatred against a segment of the population, including holocaust denial, a law very much akin in the US to "hate speech," that vilifies a person or a community based on race, religion and ethnicity. Certainly if the federal authorities in Washington were to determine that that a buffoon in California with a cheap video camera, who shot a crudely made Islamophobe film, had intentionally released it in order to "persuade, encourage, instigate or pressure" others to commit violence, the buffoon would have been arrested by now.
The laws are there on the books, and these laws penalize that category of speech aimed at inciting discrimination against a community because of its members' racial, religious and ethnic backgrounds. In America free speech, contrary to how Arabs and other Muslims have read President Obama's speech at the UN on Tuesday, is not a free for all. Not only hate crimes, and hate speech intended to incite, are against the law, but in American culture - in its everyday manners of social exchange in the public debate - Americans are enjoined, at penalty of social ostracism, against being "politically incorrect." Political incorrectness, the tendency to be offensive to, or dismissive of, the sensibility of minorities, is not a crime, but it comes at a price, at times a heavy price indeed.
And when you consider the case in 1999 of David Howard (a case I was peripherally involved in), then we are looking at an extreme price, exacted by a kind of semantic police. Howard, an aide to the then new mayor of Washington, was made to resign (read, fired) because he was quoted in the media as having said, haplessly, that he would use his budget "in a niggardly manner." Niggardly, of course, is a perfectly legitimate word in the lexicon with etymological roots in old Swedish, meaning "to be frugal." Unfortunately for the mayoral aide, who just happened to be white, niggardly sounded too much like the racial slur associated with the N-word.
Trust me on this one: The overwhelming majority of Americans do not condone bigotry, of which Islamophobia is but one expression. But they do value free speech, and the thought of restricting it is anathema to the very ethos of their political culture.
That's what President Obama was talking about at the UN. And President Mursi did not, at a seminal level, disagree with his American counterpart's speech so much as with its modalities - a simple case of how two different societies see, read and interpret the meaning of freedom of expression in the public domain. So let's all get a grip and move on.

Fawaz Turki


  MENA News Headlines
Apr 23 2014China Calls for Inclusive Political Transition in Syria ,Qatar News Agency
(MENAFN - Qatar News Agency) ijing April 23 - China called on all parties in Syria to continue advancing the Geneva peace talks and start an inclusive political transition as soon as ...

Apr 23 2014UAE- Dh154 billion for Arabtec projects ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Arabtec will spend dh140 billion on building one million low-cost houses in egypt and dh14 billion on five mixed-use residential projects in abu dhabi and dubai its chief ...

Apr 23 2014Abu Dhabi Racing take fourth spot ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Sunday night saw the end of 6hrs silverstone first round of world endurance championship 25 minutes short of its original duration due to heavy rains. khaled al ...

Apr 23 2014Dubai Chamber highlights trade potential of Latam ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Mexico brazil chile and argentina in focus for investment the dubai chamber of commerce and industry has issued four studies compiled by the economist intelligence ...

Apr 23 2014UAE- Indian falls to death in Abu Shagara ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) The police investigation has shown that the 32-year-old indian man whose body was found lying in abu shagara died after he fell from a multi-storey building in the ...

Apr 23 2014UAE- 100 objects 100 days: A collection of art works from antiquity ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) The 100 objects on display most of which are lent from the british museum may be viewed for 100 days until august 1 when they will return to london. a granite statue of ...

Apr 23 2014Egypt- Al-Azhar denounces violence practiced against Myanmar's Rohingyas ,Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) Al-Azhar has expressed deep concern over prosecutions carried out by Myanmar authorities against Muslim citizens (Rohingyas) and the violation of their rights, ...

Apr 23 2014Kuwait's insurer gains KD 4.6 bln in FY 2012-13 revenues ,Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) The Public Institution for Social Security has earned revenues of KD 4.6 billion (USD 16.3 billion) for the FY 2012-13, a hike of KD 643 million (USD 2.7 billion) ...

Apr 23 2014French, German FMs to visit Tunisia April 24-25 ,Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius, accompanied by his German counterpart Frank-Walter Steinmeier, will visit Tunisia on April 24-25 to convey a strong ...

Apr 23 2014France condemns assassination of two Somali lawmakers ,Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) France condemned on Tuesday the assassination of two Somali lawmakers in the capital Mogadishu, and called for boosting efforts in combating terrorism and bring ...

Apr 23 2014Britain denounces massacres S. Sudan ,Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) The British government strongly condemned on Tuesday criminal acts by armed men in South Sudan, especially in Bentiu and Bor cities which resulted in killing ...

Apr 23 2014Emirates NBD opens branch at Wafi Mall ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Emirates nbd on tuesday announced the opening of its new branch at wafi mall which is in line with the bank?s strategy to focus on customer centricity and convenient ...

Apr 23 2014UAE- Dewa and GE explore collaboration opportunities ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Saeed mohammed al tayer managing director and chief executive officer of the dubai electricity and water authority (dewa) recently received a ge delegation to explore ...

Apr 23 2014UAE- Sale of Gate Towers penthouses launched ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Aldar properties has launched the sale of 21 exclusive duplex penthouse apartments at gate towers the penthouse collection in shams abu dhabi on al reem island. one of ...

Apr 23 2014Al Ittihad wary of Al Ain ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Teams eye group c lead to take advantage of playing at home in knockouts al ain players celebrate their victory against tractorsazi tabriz (iran) in the afc champions ...

Apr 23 2014UAE- Gitex Shopper Spring 2014 to open doors today ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Gitex shopper spring 2014 is set to open doors today with best bargains on latest tech products along with millions of dirhams worth of prizes during the four-day ...

Apr 23 2014Improve hygiene standards to limit spread of Mers-CoV ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) The arab hygiene council has stressed on the need for increased levels of hygiene as a preventative measure against middle east respiratory syndrome-coronavirus ...

Apr 23 2014Sandstorm in Dubai' Najm Sohail app will tell you ,Khaleej Times
(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Early weather warning mobile app launched residents and authorities can now prepare for dusty and stormy conditions in dubai 48 hours in advance with just a click on ...

Apr 23 2014Arab League condemns Israeli transgressions against Al-Aqsa Mosque ,Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) The Arab League denounced Tuesday the continued Israeli transgressions against Al-Aqsa Mosque, the Muslim's third holiest worship place, in East Jerusalem. In ...

Apr 23 2014Oman to post 4 percent growth in its economy in 2014 ,MENAFN
(MENAFN) Oman's economy is expected to grow by 4-5 percent in 2014 after implementing multi-billion projects in 2013 and 2012, according to Arab News. Head of the Gulf country"s central bank said ...


Click to Apply



Middle East North Africa - Financial Network

MENAFN News Market Data Countries Tools Section  

Middle East North Africa - Financial Network

Main News
News By Industry
News By Country
Marketwatch News
UPI News
Comtex News

IPO News
Islamic Finance News
Private Equity News

How-To Guides
Technology Section

Travel Section

Search News

Market Indices
Quotes & Charts

Global Indices
Arab Indices

US Markets Details


Oil & Energy

Currencies Cross Rates
Currencies Updates
Currency Converter

USA Stocks
Arab Stocks

Saudi Arabia 

Investment Game
Economic Calendar
Financial Glossary

Portfolio Tracker


Financial Calculators

RSS Feeds [XML]

Corporate Monitor


Real Estate
Submit Your Property

Arab Research
Buy a Research

Press Releases
Submit your PR

Join Newsletters

© 2000 menafn.com All Rights Reserved.  Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Advertise | About MENAFN | Career Opportunities | Feedback | Help