MENAFN - Arab News
MENA and Egypt are like an upside down Europe
(MENAFN - Arab News) Commenting on Egypt is not something I take lightly, particularly when the death toll there continues to rise.
The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) is a difficult region to comment on in general.
You cannot apply the usual economic models when doing your research, but have to make a careful assessment of evidence on the ground and by observing the evolution of long-term general trends.
MENA is losing momentum despite the strong growth witnessed in oil-producing countries.
MENA is now divided into two halves: the north versus the south.
This is not unlike in Europe, just with a bit of role reversal.
In Europe, the north looks healthy and must figure out how to dig the south out of its economic woes.
In MENA, it's the south trying to keep the north out of political trouble as they fear the risk of a spillover from the rising tide of popular demand for democracy and more political accountability for the predicaments of their economy and society.
That's probably not the diplomatic version, but it is the reality of the situation.
Until recently, few countries in MENA even operated with three to five-year budgets.
The growth policy, more often than not, has simply been driven by oil prices, the need to hastily create jobs and satisfy the most basic material needs of the population.
This worked for a time for MENA when there was no political volatility.
But with the opening of the political dimension, the game has changed and MENA governments aren't prepared for the challenges, having failed to reform economically or politically before their economies peaked in 2007.
This leaves economic and political systems in place that are dominated by transfer incomes.
Again, this is not unlike the EU.
Egypt is about to lose its financial aid and probably also military aid from the US due to conditions in the Camp David accord with Israel.
Meanwhile, neighboring countries with an enormous interest in seeing a stable outcome have quickly donated 12 billion in aid to Egypt to mainly secure the purchase of wheat, as Egypt remains one of the world's biggest wheat importers (mainly from the US).
For a non-emotional observer, Egypt is a paradox.
A democratically elected president and government have been overthrown by the same military that removed the dictator Hosni Mubarak. Fast forward only one year and the democracy mandate has been diluted.
The main political factions are now entrenched with nowhere to go.
A compromise looks impossible as returning the ousted president to office will not happen.
The inability to deal with new paradigms for young countries shouldn't be a surprise if we take the historical perspective.
Historically, newly born countries will swing like a pendulum from one extreme to another as they search out some kind of equilibrium.
The old democracies of Europe are a product of centuries of evolution through all manner of political regimes. But despite this knowledge, we insist new democracies adopt higher democracy standards almost overnight.
Look no further than Iraq and Afghanistan to find major failures in giving these economies the time to grow, learn and adopt this difficult task of creating a smoothly functioning political economy.
In terms of the market impact from Egypt, I doubt the oil price is more than perhaps 2 higher due to the geopolitical risk.
The real risk is not having the Suez Canal open, which all involved parties, including the US, want to secure. Should they fail, it would mean 20 to 25 of extra premium on top of the current geopolitical risk.
The stock markets in the region are a different story.
The equity market in Egypt is still trading, although it's 60 percent lower compared with its peak in 2007. However, the capitalization of these markets is smaller than most S&P 500 companies.
Looking at a map, I'm concerned that the northern part of the MENA region is now in deep turmoil. Syria, Jordan, Egypt and the Palestinian territories are going from bad to worse economically. Add to this the headlines of cash shortages in Iran and we have a region that is highly flammable, both economically and politically.
Few companies, despite the oil, are willing or able to risk putting people on the ground in these countries for now.
Tourists are no-shows and the capital flight from northern MENA will continue to flow to the UAE and its commercial center of Dubai, where already bubble-prone economies could become even more leveraged.
I find it hard to reconcile headlines of Egypt spinning out of control with
Bloomberg's main MENA story recently: "Dubai sees need for tallest office tower amid 45 percent vacancy."
It turns out that the negative emerging markets story now carries over to real estate.
Elsewhere, Abu Dhabi's central business district vacancy rate is at 38 percent, while Mumbai is at 25 percent. Compare this with Moscow's central business district vacancy rate of 15 percent.
The fact that more people want to do business in Moscow based on this
metric clearly tells us that MENA is at risk of losing a competitive edge, driven by its oil riches as long as there is no true handover from government-owned companies to the private sector.
To keep MENA afloat, the south ' like Europe's north ' will need to provide more money, guidance and mediation.
History also tells us that long-term solutions need to be driven by respect, understanding and economic incentives coming from MENA - not from Europe or the US.
I remain confident that both Egypt and the rest of MENA will move to a better place, but before MENA finds a common voice and resolve to deal with not only Egypt, Syria, Jordan, the Palestinian territories, Iraq and Iran, we will be adding to this list of countries.
The loser in the short and medium-term is the population and the democratic process, which started in earnest last year.
But I remain positive on MENA's long-term prospects as I firmly believe in the micro economy.
The individual person, the small company that wants to do better, be faster and more transparent will prevail despite the institutional headwinds.
MENA News Headlines
|Dec 12 2013||Oman Gas Company (OGC) plans to two big projects ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Oman Gas Company (OGC) has announced its plan of two big projects as part of its plan of extracting commercially valuable components from natural gas flowing through its huge gas ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Saudi to invest in Azerbaijanï¿½s petrochemical industry ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Saudi Arabia has announced its plan to invest in Azerbaijan"s petrochemical and refining industry, the head of Saudi Arabian General Investment Authority Abdullatif Al Othman said, according ...|
|Dec 12 2013||Abu Dhabi's DED captures USD9.5 m worth of counterfeit products ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Abu Dhabi Department of Economic Development (DED) has seized 139.000 tons, or USD9.527 million worth, of counterfeit products during the current year, according to Gulf News.
|Dec 11 2013||Emaar's new villas sold out within an hour of release ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) The newly released villas on Emaar's Dubai Hills project were sold out in one hour, Arabian Business reported.
Around 70 buyers were selected to bid on the villas with a price starting ...|
|Dec 11 2013||Saudi Arabia to invest USD1.39b to build reform centers ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Saudi Arabia is planning to build four new reform centers for USD1.39 billion, Arabian Business reported.
Head of the DP Engineering Section said that the first reform center will ...|
|Dec 11 2013||UAE to add 29 million passengers by 2017 ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) The International Air Transport Association (IATA) forecasted that UAE, through its carriers Emirates and Etihad, will add 29.2 million passengers until 2017, Arabian Business ...|
|Dec 11 2013||SKAI to commence work on Viceroy Dubai ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Dubai's SKAI Holdings announced that it will commence structural work on a USD1 billion project on Palm Jumeirah, Arabian Business reported.
The Viceroy Dubai Palm Jumeirah project, a ...|
|Dec 11 2013||KSA plans USD4b water storage projects ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) Saudi Arabia is planning to invest USD4 billion to develop water storage projects in the country, Arabian Business reported
National Water Company CEO said that the first water storage ...|
|Dec 11 2013||Transaction in Qatari real estate at USD1.6b in Nov. ,MENAFN|
|(MENAFN) The Qatari real estate market logged USD1.6 billion in transactions last month, The Peninsula reported.
Transactions in Al Rayan Municipality came at USD576.3 million in the month, while ...|
|Dec 11 2013||Jordans Long-Term Foreign and Local Currency Ratings Lowered Outlook Revised to Stable ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) 11th December 2013
Jordan's Long-Term Foreign and Local Currency Ratings Lowered; Outlook Revised to 'Stable'.
Capital Intelligence (CI) today announced that ...|
|Dec 11 2013||Bin Faqeeh to be Top-level
Sponsor of Gulf Property Show
|(MENAFN Press) Bin Faqeeh Real Estate Investment Company, a leading developer with a portfolio of high-end residential, commercial and leisure projects either completed, under construction or planned ...|
|Dec 11 2013||Al Qasba to ring out the year with spectacular Street Fiesta ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) The walkways of Al Qasba are all set to erupt in an explosion of fun and entertainment this month as Sharjah's premier leisure destination prepares to host the spectacular Al Qasba ...|
|Dec 11 2013||J.P. Morgan Private Bank - FX Weekly Report 11th December 2013 ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) USD: Q1 Tapering still seems likely:
Last week brought a run of strong US data, which was topped off by another robust employment report. Non Farm payrolls came in significantly ...|
|Dec 11 2013||Tamkeen Business Quiz Grand Finale Set for 12 December ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) FinMark Communications and Tamkeen are set to host the Final Night of the Third Annual Tamkeen Business Quiz Show on 12th December 2013 at the new extension of the Al Aali Shopping ...|
|Dec 11 2013||StÃ©phane Michel appointed President Middle East, ExplorationProduction Division at Total ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) Effective January 1, 2014, StÃ©phane Michel is appointed President Middle East, Exploration & Production Division at Total. He will report to Arnaud Breuillac, President, Exploration ...|
|Dec 11 2013||Samsung Electronics Levant Holds "Note 3 Art Gallery" for Jordanian Artist Samer Al Kurdi ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) Samsung Electronics Levant, a global leader in digital media and digital convergence technologies, celebrated the launch of "Note 3 Art Gallery" by Jordanian artist Samer Al Kurdi, ...|
|Dec 11 2013||Samsonites Synconn Collection - Essential work companion for business travellers
|(MENAFN Press) Samsonite â€“ the world leaders in travel luggage solutions, has announced the regional launch of its latest collection, Synconn â€“ the essential business companion that synchronises ...|
|Dec 11 2013||Coral Beach Resort - Sharjah Supports 7 Emirates Run ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) The Coral Beach Resort â€“ Sharjah extended whole-hearted support to the 7 Emirates Run, a 575-kilometre ultra-marathon led by veteran runner Mr Wendelin Lauxen, by hosting the ...|
|Dec 11 2013||J.P. Morgan Private Bank Reveals Sentiment and Risk Appetite of European Investors
|(MENAFN Press) Snippets from the news announcement:
Â· Fewer are worried about the breakup of the Eurozone: 16 per cent vs. 36 per cent when compared to this time last year
|Dec 11 2013||Fashion TV CafÃ© opens with spectacular fashion fanfare ,MENAFN Press|
|(MENAFN Press) Dubai's fashion forward elite were out in full force at Emaar Boulevard this past Friday for the glittering opening of Fashion TV's first F CafÃ© in the region. The grand opening was ...|